How to Tell If You Need Toilet Repair or a Full Replacement

Nobody wants to deal with toilet problems, but they’re an inevitable part of homeownership. The key question when issues arise is whether you’re looking at a quick fix or a full replacement project. Farrell Plumbing, the go-to local plumber in Trinity, FL, explores several factors that can help you make this determination, from the age of your toilet to the type and frequency of problems you’re experiencing.

Consider the Age of the Toilet

Toilets generally last 15–20 years, but wear and tear can add up sooner. If your toilet is nearing or beyond that range, frequent plumbing repairs may no longer be worth the cost. An older unit may also be less efficient, using more water per flush than modern models.

Watch for Recurring Issues

If you’re constantly calling for professional plumbing services to address issues—whether it’s clogs, running water, or flushing problems—it may be time to consider a replacement. One-off matters can often be fixed affordably, but repeated malfunctions are a sign that the system is no longer as reliable as before.

Check for Physical Damage

Cracks in the tank or bowl, even if small, can lead to serious leaks and water damage. While some minor cracks may be patched, any structural damage typically requires a full replacement to prevent more significant problems or even emergency plumbing situations.

Evaluate Water Efficiency

As mentioned earlier, older toilets can use up to 6 gallons of water per flush. On the other hand, newer models are designed to be more water-efficient, using only 1.6 gallons or less per flush. If you’re looking to save on your water bill and do your part for the environment, upgrading to a more efficient toilet is definitely worth considering.

If you need help making the decision on whether to repair or replace your toilet, it’s always best to consult a reputable plumbing company like Farrell Plumbing. You can count on our experienced technicians to assess the situation and provide you with the most cost-effective solution. Call us today or fill out our online form to schedule an appointment.